US-based Ghanaian legal scholar Prof. Stephen Kwaku Asare, popularly known as Kwaku Azar, has criticised the Ghana Tertiary Education Commission’s (GTEC) decision to freeze new PhD admissions nationwide, describing the measure as disproportionate.
In a Facebook post reacting to the announcement, Prof. Asare acknowledged the need to protect the quality of doctoral education but questioned why all tertiary institutions should be affected when concerns may be limited to particular programmes.
“The objective is commendable. Ghanaian doctoral qualifications must command respect at home and abroad,” he stated.
However, he argued that the Commission should focus on institutions that fail to meet academic standards rather than impose restrictions on all universities.
“Regulating doctoral quality is GTEC’s responsibility; suspending doctoral opportunity across otherwise compliant institutions requires compelling justification,” he said.
His comments follow an announcement by GTEC Director-General, Prof. Abdullah Jinapor, that new PhD admissions would be suspended pending a nationwide audit of doctoral programmes.
The audit is expected to examine accreditation, student enrolment, supervisory capacity, research facilities, completion rates and the integrity of thesis examinations.
Prof. Asare raised six questions about the decision, including its legal basis, the evidence supporting the nationwide suspension and the measures being taken to protect students already enrolled in doctoral programmes.
He also questioned why the audit could not proceed while institutions that meet the required standards continue admitting students.
According to him, the number of students admitted into a programme does not necessarily determine the quality of doctoral training.
“A programme with 52 students and 25 qualified supervisors may be better equipped than one with 15 students and two supervisors. Capacity, not headcount, determines adequacy,” he explained.
The legal scholar further called on GTEC to publish the audit timetable, assessment criteria and procedures for lifting restrictions on institutions that meet the required standards.
As an alternative, he proposed a five-point approach involving targeted audits, admission limits based on supervisory capacity, protection for existing students, continuous quality assurance and graduated sanctions against non-compliant institutions.
He recommended that universities with adequate facilities and qualified supervisors should be allowed to continue admitting PhD students while institutions with serious deficiencies face appropriate restrictions.
Prof. Asare also questioned GTEC’s oversight role, asking how institutions allegedly operating beyond their capacity were able to obtain or retain accreditation.
“If institutions have been admitting doctoral students beyond their supervisory and research capacity, how did those programmes obtain or retain accreditation?” he asked.
He maintained that any audit should examine both the performance of universities and the effectiveness of GTEC’s accreditation and monitoring systems.
“The answer to deficient doctoral programmes is targeted enforcement. The answer to deficient oversight is continuous quality assurance. Neither requires an indiscriminate nationwide freeze,” he concluded.
No Comment! Be the first one.